I figure that if some asshole can come up with the "what's on the top twenty-five most played songs on iTunes" meme, I can come up with one, too. Maybe I'll fail--who knows.
My proposed meme is simple but it'll make you think, maybe.
The rules are as follows:
1. In no particular order, name your top ten favorite songs--ever.
2. Justify each choice.
3. The list should be completely subjective. The point is to name the ten songs you think are best, not the best songs you think everyone else thinks are best.
So, here's my list (remember, in no particular order) (these are all taken from my iTunes "Best songs... EVER!" list, that is, songs that have earned a five-star rating on iTunes).
1. Soma - The Smashing Pumpkins
Yes, I have to start with a song by this band. And this is their best song ever, in my opinion. It's long, and Billy Corgan rules at writing long songs. It's about breaking up, being alone, being let down. It features some of my favorite lyrics, for example: "Didn't want to lose you once again, didn't want to be your friend. Fulfilled a promise made of tin, crawled back to you" and "I'm all by myself, as I've always felt." And it features one of the most amazing guitar solos I've ever heard. Plus, the soft-to-loud transition is amongs the best. So this song is definitely amongst one of my favorites.
2. The Boxer - Simon & Garfunkel
This song is absolutely incomparable, in my opinion. This would be my choice for best song, objectively speaking, ever. It's just . . . amazing. It's a song about being so lonely that you take comfort in whores. A song about persevering, even if you just want to give up. "In the clearing stands a boxer, and a fighter by his trade, and he carries the reminders of every glove that laid him down or cut him till he cried out, in his anger and his shame, I am leaving, I am leaving, but the fighter still remains." It's a song about not giving up, even after you feel like you've lost. It's an amazing song.
3. Hey - The Pixies
I can think of few songs that I'd rather sing along to at 4am while smoking rollie cigarettes with my friends. This song resonates with me, even if I can't identify exactly why. I think it has something to do with the theme of being separated, by whores in your head, whores at the door, or whores in your bed, from someone. I don't know--I just really love this song. "If you go, I will surely die."
4. Only in Dreams - Weezer
I don't think any song in the universe captures what it's like to be me more than this song. You like a girl, you can't avoid her, she's in the air. But the whole thing is impossible. And you know it. And she knows it. And nothing could ever change that. Things are only different in movies--or in your dreams. This song is a perfect expression of those emotions, from the verses, to the chorus, to the extended slow-down, speed-up section. "You say it's a good thing that you float in the air, that way there's no way I will crush your pretty toenails into a thousand pieces." Just amazing.
5. Untitled 8 - Sigur Ros
This is the only song, and in fact the only thing, that has ever caused me to undergo what I would call a religious experience. It was at the Sigur Ros show I went to (they're an awesome live band, by the way). It was the most intense feeling of love and peace I've ever experienced. It was just unprecedented. Although this song cannot fully explain that experience, the experience would not have bene possible without the song.
Although later events tainted the experience, causing me to avoid listening to this song for fear of remembering how things were and how things shoudl have been, I've never forgotten the feeling, and I've never stopped associating it with this song.
6. Beck - Nobody's Fault but My Own
The first time I heard this song, I was in high school and Beck was performing it live on SNL. I was blown away. Something about the combination of haunting music, performed by exotic instruments, and un-straighforward lyrics, delivered in a way that's both confident and remorseful, made me instantly love the song. I went out and bought Mutations the very next day, and it remains my favorite Beck album.
7. Street Spirit (Fade Out) - Radiohead
If you know anything about anything, I don't think I should have to justify this choice. This song is just pure genius, at once beautiful and ridiculously depressing, if this song doesn't take you from whatever mood you're in and put you in its mood, then you're just an idiot. Thom Yorke has said that this song is exhausting to play, and it's just as exhausting to listen to. But that's a good thing, I think.
8. Cherub Rock - The Smashing Pumpkins
I first bought Siamese Dream over ten years ago and, for my money, there's still not a better "get up and go" song than this one. Everything, from the drum intro to the awesome guitar build-up, to the guitar solo, to the lyrics make this song one of my top choices for starting a road trip off on the right foot, getting dressed for a good day, or just getting myself out of a funk. You can't help but tap your foot to this song. It's just great.
9. Rebellion (Lies) - The Arcade Fire
Some of my favorite memories are from nights when I didn't sleep at all (Monopoly, anyone?). I've always been a night person, and I've always hated the fact that, at some point, your body makes you sleep. So why wouldn't I love the lyrics "sleeping is giving in, no matter what the time is. Sleeping is giving in, so lift those heavy eyelids."
10. Whir - The Smashing Pumpkins
The fact is that it's been very hard for me to come up with the tenth song. At any given time, any song by The Smashing Pumpkins, Weezer, The Pixies, or any other number of bands might take up this spot. Right now, tonight, though, this is the song. I've loved this song since the first time I heard it (which I remember very distinctly). It's mellow but still up-beat. It's just an all-around awesome song, in my opinion. "My honey, little girl, c'mon, let's go for a whir!"
Honorable mention:
The Wind - Cat Stevens (would have made it except it's just too short. But what there is is awesome); Thru the Eyes of Ruby - The Smashing Pumpkins (one of my favorite songs on Mellon Collie); The Only Living Boy in New York - Simon & Garfunkel ("I get the news I need from the weather report."); Rocket Man - Elton John (a song so awesome not even William Shatner could ruin it for me); Virginia Reel Around the Fountain - Built to Spill; Wave of Mutilation (UK Surf Mix); Worry Wort - Radiohead; Zombie - The Cranberries (perhaps this one's controversial, but I really, really like this song); When I Come Around - Green Day (Dookie was the first CD I ever bought, based almost entirely on the awesomeness of this song).
There are just so many awesome songs. So, now, your mission, should you choose to accept it: list your favorite ten songs, in no particular order, on your own blog or, if you don't have a blog, in the comments here.